MATH STRATEGIES: What's Awesome and What's < Awesome

Listed below are best practices for teaching mathematics as listed in the publication Best Practice, Today's Standards for Teaching and Learning in America's Schools by Steven Zemelman, Harvey Daniels, Arthur Hyde.  Many of you received this book as part of a reading grant last year.

WHAT'S AWESOME                                                         
WHAT'S LESS THAN AWESOME

TEACHING PRACTICES                                                   TEACHING PRACTICES                                              

Use of manipulative materials                                            Rote practice
Cooperative group work                                                     Rote memorization of rules and formulas
Discussion of mathematics                                                Teaching by telling (lecture)     
Justification of thinking                                                       Single answers and single methods to find answers
Writing about mathematics                                                 Stressing memorization instead of understanding
Problem-solving approach to instruction                            Repetitive written practice
Content integration                                                             Use of drill worksheets
Use of calculators and computers                                      Teaching computation out of context
Being a facilitator of learning                                              Reliance on paper and pencil calculations
Assessing learning as an integral part of instruction          Being the dispenser of knowledge


PROBLEM SOLVING                                                         PROBLEM SOLVING

Word problems with a variety of structures and                 Use of cue words to determine operation to be used
solution paths
Everyday problems and applications
Problem-solving strategies (especially                               Practicing problems categorized by types
representational strategies)
Open-ended problems and extended                                 Practicing routine, one-step problems
problem-solving projects
Investigating and formulating questions from 
problem situations

CREATING REPRESENTATIONS                                      CREATING REPRESENTATIONS

Creating one's own representations that make                   Copying conventional representations without understanding
sense
Creating multiple representations of the same                    Reliance on a few representations
problem or situation
Translating between representations of the same               Premature introduction of highly abstract representations
problem or situation
Representations using electronic technology
Using representations to make the abstract ideas               Forms of representations as an end product or goal
more concrete
Using representations to build understanding of
concepts through reflection
Sharing representations to communicate ideas

COMMUNICATING MATH IDEAS                                       COMMUNICATING MATH IDEAS                                     

Discussing mathematics                                                      Doing fill-in-the-blank worksheets
Reading mathematics                                                          Answering questions that need only yes or no answers
Writing mathematics                                                            Answering questions that need only numerical answers
Listening to mathematical ideas

REASONING AND PROOF                                                 REASONING AND PROOF

Drawing logical conclusions                                                Relying on authorities (teacher or answer key)
Justifying answers and solution processes
Reasoning inductively and deductively

MAKING CONNECTIONS                                                   MAKING CONNECTIONS

Connecting mathematics to other subjects and                   Learning isolated topics
to the real world
Connecting topics within mathematics                                Developing skills out of context
Applying mathematics

NUMBERS/OPERATIONS/COMPUTATION                       NUMBERS/OPERATIONS/COMPUTATION

Developing number and operation sense                            Early use of symbolic notation
Understanding the meaning of key concepts such
as place value, fractions, decimals, ratios,                          Memorizing rules and procedures without understanding
proportions, and percents
Various estimation strategies                                               Complex and tedious paper and pencil computations
Thinking strategies for basic facts
Using calculators for complex calculations

GEOMETRY/MEASUREMENT                                            GEOMETRY/MEASUREMENT

Developing spatial sense                                                      Memorizing facts and relationships
Actual measuring and exploring the concepts                      Memorizing equivalencies between units of measure
related to units of measure                                                   Memorizing geometric formulas
Using geometry in problem solving

STATISTICS/PROBABILITY                                                STATISTICS/PROBABILITY

Collecting and organizing data                                             Memorizing formulas
Using statistical methods to describe analyze
evaluate, and make decisions

ALGEBRA                                                                            ALGEBRA

Recognizing and describing patterns                                   Manipulating symbols
Identifying and using functional relationships
Developing and using tables, graphs, and rules                  Memorizing procedures
to describe situations
Using variables to express relationships

ASSESSMENT                                                                    ASSESSMENT

Making assessment an integral part of teaching                 Having assessment be simply counting correct answers on test
Focusing on a broad range of mathematical tasks              for the sole purpose of assigning grades
and taking a holistic view of mathematics                           Focusing on a large number of specific and isolated skills
Developing problem situations that require                         Using exercises or word problems requiring only one or two
applications of a number of mathematical ideas                 skills
Using multiple assessment techniques including                Using only written  tests
written, oral, and demonstration formats





Comments